Masterpiece in Progress...

Caroline Sholl • September 10, 2026

You are God’s handiwork—and He isn’t finished yet.

When we hear the word masterpiece, we often picture something flawless: a beautiful painting hanging in a museum, perfectly finished and admired by everyone who sees it. So when Christians say, “You are God’s masterpiece,” it can sometimes feel difficult to believe. If I’m God’s masterpiece, why do I have so many flaws? Why do I struggle with the things I struggle with? Why have I made so many mistakes? Why are there parts of myself I wish were different?


Perhaps we misunderstand what makes something a masterpiece. A masterpiece is not valuable because every part of it is perfect. It is valuable because of the artist who created it, the intention with which it was made, and the love, thought, and purpose poured into its creation.


You Are His Handiwork


Ephesians 2:10 tells us, “For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them.” Depending on the Bible translation you use, the word translated as workmanship may also appear as handiwork or masterpiece. The original Greek word is poiēma, meaning something that has been made—a work of the maker.


That gives us a beautiful way of understanding ourselves: you are something God made. You were not mass-produced. You were not an afterthought. God did not accidentally give you your personality, your particular gifts, your sensitivity, your intensity, your intellect, your sense of humor, your capacity to love, or the countless little things that make you distinctly yourself. God intended you.


Psalm 139 expresses this same truth: “For you formed my inward parts; you knitted me together in my mother’s womb.” The psalmist responds, “I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made.” Scripture does not describe our creation as random or impersonal. It describes a God who knows us intimately and creates with intention.


God Is an Artist


In his Letter to Artists, Pope John Paul II reflected on God as the original Creator and wrote that every person is entrusted with the task of making his or her life “a work of art, a masterpiece.” Whether or not we come from the same Christian tradition as John Paul II, the image is a powerful one because it reflects something we see throughout Scripture: God is both our Creator and the One who continues to work within us.


That means a masterpiece can still be in progress.


God created you intentionally, but He did not create you as a finished product who would never struggle, change, fail, learn, suffer, or grow. We are created in the image of God, but we also live in a fallen world. We carry wounds. We develop unhealthy patterns. We make poor choices. Other people hurt us, and sometimes we hurt other people. There may be parts of ourselves that genuinely need healing and change. None of that means the Artist made a mistake.


Imperfection Is Not the Same as Worthlessness


Sometimes we unconsciously believe that our worth rises and falls according to how well we are doing. We may believe that we are lovable when we are kind, valuable when we are productive, good when we make the right decisions, worthy when other people approve of us, beautiful when our bodies look a certain way, or acceptable to God when we are behaving well.


The Gospel tells us something radically different: our worth is not something we earn through our performance. We are created in God’s image and deeply loved by Him. Romans 5:8 reminds us that “while we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” God did not wait for us to become polished, healed, obedient, or impressive before loving us.


This doesn’t mean everything we do is good. It doesn’t mean sin doesn’t matter or that we never need to change. Christianity takes repentance and transformation very seriously. But there is an enormous difference between saying, “There are things in me that need healing,” and believing, “There is something fundamentally wrong with me.” There is a difference between saying, “I did something wrong,” and believing, “I am a mistake.” God may want to change something in you without wishing He had created someone instead of you.


Think About a Handmade Work of Art


Imagine a beautiful piece of handmade pottery. It may have slight variations in its shape. You might see evidence of the hands that formed it. Its glaze may be darker in one place and lighter in another. It may not have the mathematical uniformity of something produced by a machine. Those differences do not make the piece meaningless or worthless. They remind us that it was made by someone.


Or imagine an old stained-glass window. Some pieces are brilliantly colored, while others are dark. Some are irregularly shaped. Viewed individually, a particular piece might not seem especially beautiful, but the artist knows where it belongs. The beauty is revealed when we step back and see the whole.


We often examine ourselves one piece at a time: I don’t like this part of my personality. I wish this hadn’t happened to me. I wish I weren’t so sensitive. I wish I hadn’t made that mistake. I wish I looked different. I wish my story were different. And while we are staring at one small piece, God sees the whole window.


Your Wounds Are Not Your Identity


There is another important distinction: not everything that has happened to you was God’s design. Sometimes Christians say, “Everything happens for a reason,” in a way that can make it sound as though every painful experience was deliberately chosen by God. But Scripture gives us a more complicated picture. Human beings have free will. Sin is real. People hurt one another. Bodies become sick. Relationships break. We live in a world that is not yet as it should be.


Yet Scripture repeatedly shows us a God who is able to redeem what is broken. Romans 8:28 tells us that God works in all things for the good of those who love Him. That does not mean that everything that happens is good. It means God is capable of working even within what is not good.


God can redeem and restore. He can bring beauty out of places that once held tremendous pain. A scar is not proof that the original creation was worthless. A scar tells us that there has been a wound and that healing has taken place. Your wounds may become part of your story, but they do not get to define your worth.


The Artist Is Still Working


Perhaps one of the most freeing things we can understand is that God is not finished with us yet. Philippians 1:6 tells us that “he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion.” You do not have to look at yourself today and decide that this is the final version.


The impatient person can become more patient. The frightened person can become courageous. The person who has spent years pleasing everyone else can learn healthy boundaries. The person carrying shame can learn to receive grace. The person who has been wounded can heal. The person who has sinned can repent and begin again. The person who has forgotten who she is can rediscover her identity in Christ.


Christianity is not a story about proving that we were perfect all along. It is the story of creation, brokenness, redemption, and restoration. God creates. Sin wounds. Christ redeems. Grace transforms. Through all of it, the Artist does not abandon His work.


Maybe You Don’t Need to Become Someone Else


Many of us spend years trying to construct a version of ourselves that we believe will finally be worthy of love: prettier, thinner, smarter, more successful, less emotional, more agreeable, more impressive, more productive, less needy, more spiritual, or less complicated.


But healing does not necessarily mean becoming a completely different person. Sometimes healing means allowing God to uncover the person He intended before fear, shame, comparison, wounds, sin, and other people’s expectations began telling us who we were supposed to be. The goal isn’t perfection. The goal is wholeness—becoming more fully the person God created you to be.


2 Corinthians 3:18 describes the Christian life as a process of being transformed into the image of Christ “from one degree of glory to another.” Transformation is a process. God works patiently. Growth happens over time. The fact that there is still work to be done does not mean the work already present has no value.


You Are Deliberately and Lovingly Made


So when you hear the words You are God’s masterpiece, don’t hear, “Everything about me is perfect.” Instead, hear this: I was wanted. I was made deliberately. My life has meaning. My dignity does not disappear when I struggle. My mistakes are things I have done; they are not the definition of who I am. My wounds are part of my story, but they are not the author of my story. There are things in me God wants to heal and transform, and the Artist has not walked away from His work.


You don’t have to be flawless to be God’s workmanship, and you don’t have to be finished to be His masterpiece. You can be deeply loved by God and still have growing to do. You can be His handiwork and still need healing. You can have weaknesses and still have purpose. You can have a complicated story and still be a beautiful work of God.


Perhaps that is a better way to understand a masterpiece: not something that was always perfect, but something deliberately conceived, lovingly made, patiently worked upon, and treasured by the Artist who created it.

By Caroline Sholl September 7, 2026
Below is an audio recording of a talk my husband, Brian, and I gave on living a joy-filled marriage. Enjoy!
By Caroline Sholl August 10, 2026
Healing Our Wounds So We Are Free to Love
By Caroline Sholl July 30, 2026
How to trade control for influence without losing connection
By Caroline Sholl July 29, 2026
The Ancient Battle Behind Our Modern Restlessness
By Beth Maillho January 27, 2026
At the end of every appointment, I have my clients pick a Scripture verse, I call it their “anchor verse” for the week. They pull a random card from a deck of 100 with beautiful angel paintings on them, each with a unique Scripture verse on the other side. It's usually how the Holy Spirit puts the exclamation point on our time together. Well, this experience with the Scripture verses had me jumping out of my chair! It unfolded slowly, involving five of six clients in a row over two days. It started with a male client when he pulled his anchor verse. “A friend is one who loves at all times, and a brother is born for a time of adversity.” – Proverbs 17:17 It confused me at first, trying to understand the difference between a friend and a brother. We talked about it a little bit and how it applied to his life. My next appointment was with another man. He pulled the same Bible verse even though the deck had been shuffled. Interesting... I now understood the verse a bit more, that a brother born for a time of adversity is the person who enters into the battle with you. They are a next-level friend. They are your Battle Buddy , part of your army platoon. I feel like I am this client’s Battle Buddy, and even said to him in full excitement, “Let’s gooooooo!” Appointment #3. I shuffled the deck, and yet, he pulled the exact same Bible verse! Holy Spirit, what are you doing?? I started paying closer attention. What are the odds of three in a row? This was the last appointment for the day and gave me much to think about. The next morning, I came in early and freshened up my office. I shuffled the deck, chuckling to myself. Appointment #4 with a couple. Time for the verse. The client read Proverbs 17:17. Again! I couldn’t believe it. The Holy Spirit was clearly at work. I said, “I’m your Battle Buddy, you are each other’s Battle Buddy, and we are going to fight for this marriage.” Appointment #5 was my first appointment with a new female client. It was time for her to pull a verse, and she… broke the streak. Her verse was the Bible verse for WayMaker Ministries, which is Jeremiah 29:11. “For I know the plans I have for you … a future full of hope.” It was the perfect confirmation not only for her story, but for my calling. I know these Scripture cards aren’t supposed to be about me, but God does speak to me through their verses at times. Appointment #6 was a male. I didn’t expect anything at this point. Silly me. He. Pulled. The. Same. Proverbs 17:17 verse! I just couldn't believe it. I told him everything that had happened over the past two days and explained the verse. I was his Battle Buddy, and more importantly, another prominent person in his life was his life-long Battle Buddy. “Grief work!? Let’s gooooooo!” (My clients and I have a sense of humor together at times, even with grief work.) Here’s another wild fact: four of the five who pulled that verse share a similar experience that specifically related to the Battle Buddy image. All five were men. Holy cow! Or rather Holy SPIRIT! What are the odds of that happening? Next to none. The odds of having five out of six clients pull the same verse out of a deck of 100 unique cards is 1 in 16.8 MILLION!!!! Think back to the image of the Battle Buddy. Ultimately, Jesus is our true, life-long Battle Buddy. He walks with us in adversity, in grief, in confusion, in hope, and in love. I get the privilege of walking arm-in-arm with my clients into their battles BUT with Jesus as Captain. But wait, there’s more! Just when I thought the story was finished, God added one more confirmation for me. The following weekend, I attended my annual Holy Spirit women’s retreat where a woman prayed over me. She hesitated before sharing what she saw, thinking she’d lost her mind… “I see you on your belly doing an army crawl, arm over arm, under barbed wire. Does that mean anything?” I almost fell over. Yes! It meant everything! She saw me in the battle! I’m still processing what the Holy Spirit is doing not only in my clients but also in me. Watching the Divine Counselor at work is breathtaking. His love is fierce, intentional, and relentless. He is the ultimate and constant Battle Buddy. Y’all, we hit the Jesus jackpot. We are Jesus millionaires!
By Caroline Sholl January 24, 2026
How an honest view of ourselves makes more room for God
By Caroline Sholl August 29, 2025
Loved Much, Forgiven More: Finding Freedom in Christ’s Mercy
By Caroline Sholl August 29, 2025
Embracing Hardship as the Doorway to Resurrection Life
By Caroline Sholl August 15, 2025
What the Parable of the Prodigal Son Teaches Us About Self-Care
By Caroline Sholl July 29, 2025
My sweet big sister, Kitty Cleveland, invited me to be a guest on her "First Friday Friends" Morning Glory show to talk about God's lavish generosity and how he healed me of a lifelong "thorn in the flesh." Take a look!