Raising Adults, Not Dependence

Caroline Sholl • July 30, 2026

How to trade control for influence without losing connection

One of the hardest transitions in parenting is accepting that your role has changed. You never stop being a parent, but you do stop being the primary decision-maker. When children are young, God gives parents authority. As children become adults, that authority naturally gives way to influence.


Many parents don't recognize that this transition has occurred. They continue feeling responsible for decisions that now belong to their adult son or daughter. They believe they are still protecting their child, but the adult child often experiences it as criticism, control, or a lack of confidence.

The goal of parenting is not lifelong dependence. The goal is to raise a wise, faithful adult who is capable of making decisions before God. If we have done our job well, our children eventually no longer need our permission. Instead, we hope they will continue to seek our wisdom because they value our relationship.


A parent directs. A mentor guides. A parent says, "Here's what you're going to do." A mentor says, "Help me understand how you're thinking about this." A parent assumes responsibility for the outcome. A mentor recognizes that the adult child is now responsible for the outcome.


Parents often feel anxious when their adult children make decisions they wouldn't have made themselves. That anxiety can create an overwhelming desire to step in, convince, persuade, warn, or even pressure the child into making a different choice. Unfortunately, the more pressure parents apply, the less influence they usually have. Adult children often stop sharing their lives because every conversation begins to feel like an evaluation.

Mentoring requires a tremendous amount of trust. It means believing that God loves your child even more than you do. It means recognizing that the Holy Spirit is fully capable of convicting, teaching, correcting, and guiding your child without your constant intervention.


One of the greatest differences between parenting and mentoring is the use of questions. Parents often tell. Mentors ask. Instead of immediately offering advice, a mentor becomes curious. "What are you hoping for?" What concerns you about this decision?" "What options have you considered?" "What do you think God might be inviting you to do?" Questions communicate respect. They allow adult children to think rather than simply react.


Mentoring also means allowing natural consequences to become teachers. Loving parents understandably want to spare their children from pain, but some lessons can only be learned through experience. God Himself often teaches us this way. If He allows us the dignity of making choices and learning from them, parents can do the same.


Another important shift is learning to ask permission before giving advice. Instead of saying, "Here's what you should do," a mentor might ask, "Would you like my thoughts?" That simple question honors the adult child's autonomy. Surprisingly, advice that is invited is often received much more openly than advice that is imposed.


Perhaps the greatest challenge is accepting that your child's decisions are no longer your responsibility. You are responsible for loving, praying, encouraging, and speaking truth when appropriate. You are not responsible for making every decision or preventing every mistake.

This doesn't mean becoming passive or indifferent. It means recognizing the difference between influence and control. Influence leaves room for freedom. Control does not.


A question I often ask parents is, "When your daughter is forty-five, what kind of relationship do you hope you have with her?" Most parents describe warmth, trust, honesty, frequent conversations, and closeness. Then I ask, "Does the way you're relating to her today make that future relationship more likely or less likely?" That question often helps parents realize that while control may produce short-term compliance, it frequently damages long-term connection.


One sentence summarizes the transition well: Children need parents who will protect them. Adults need parents who will believe in them. The task is no longer to manage your adult child's life. The task is to become a trusted guide whose wisdom is sought because it is offered with humility, respect, and love—not because it is demanded.

By Caroline Sholl September 10, 2026
You are God’s handiwork—and He isn’t finished yet.
By Caroline Sholl September 7, 2026
Below is an audio recording of a talk my husband, Brian, and I gave on living a joy-filled marriage. Enjoy!
By Caroline Sholl August 10, 2026
Healing Our Wounds So We Are Free to Love
By Caroline Sholl July 29, 2026
The Ancient Battle Behind Our Modern Restlessness
By Beth Maillho January 27, 2026
At the end of every appointment, I have my clients pick a Scripture verse, I call it their “anchor verse” for the week. They pull a random card from a deck of 100 with beautiful angel paintings on them, each with a unique Scripture verse on the other side. It's usually how the Holy Spirit puts the exclamation point on our time together. Well, this experience with the Scripture verses had me jumping out of my chair! It unfolded slowly, involving five of six clients in a row over two days. It started with a male client when he pulled his anchor verse. “A friend is one who loves at all times, and a brother is born for a time of adversity.” – Proverbs 17:17 It confused me at first, trying to understand the difference between a friend and a brother. We talked about it a little bit and how it applied to his life. My next appointment was with another man. He pulled the same Bible verse even though the deck had been shuffled. Interesting... I now understood the verse a bit more, that a brother born for a time of adversity is the person who enters into the battle with you. They are a next-level friend. They are your Battle Buddy , part of your army platoon. I feel like I am this client’s Battle Buddy, and even said to him in full excitement, “Let’s gooooooo!” Appointment #3. I shuffled the deck, and yet, he pulled the exact same Bible verse! Holy Spirit, what are you doing?? I started paying closer attention. What are the odds of three in a row? This was the last appointment for the day and gave me much to think about. The next morning, I came in early and freshened up my office. I shuffled the deck, chuckling to myself. Appointment #4 with a couple. Time for the verse. The client read Proverbs 17:17. Again! I couldn’t believe it. The Holy Spirit was clearly at work. I said, “I’m your Battle Buddy, you are each other’s Battle Buddy, and we are going to fight for this marriage.” Appointment #5 was my first appointment with a new female client. It was time for her to pull a verse, and she… broke the streak. Her verse was the Bible verse for WayMaker Ministries, which is Jeremiah 29:11. “For I know the plans I have for you … a future full of hope.” It was the perfect confirmation not only for her story, but for my calling. I know these Scripture cards aren’t supposed to be about me, but God does speak to me through their verses at times. Appointment #6 was a male. I didn’t expect anything at this point. Silly me. He. Pulled. The. Same. Proverbs 17:17 verse! I just couldn't believe it. I told him everything that had happened over the past two days and explained the verse. I was his Battle Buddy, and more importantly, another prominent person in his life was his life-long Battle Buddy. “Grief work!? Let’s gooooooo!” (My clients and I have a sense of humor together at times, even with grief work.) Here’s another wild fact: four of the five who pulled that verse share a similar experience that specifically related to the Battle Buddy image. All five were men. Holy cow! Or rather Holy SPIRIT! What are the odds of that happening? Next to none. The odds of having five out of six clients pull the same verse out of a deck of 100 unique cards is 1 in 16.8 MILLION!!!! Think back to the image of the Battle Buddy. Ultimately, Jesus is our true, life-long Battle Buddy. He walks with us in adversity, in grief, in confusion, in hope, and in love. I get the privilege of walking arm-in-arm with my clients into their battles BUT with Jesus as Captain. But wait, there’s more! Just when I thought the story was finished, God added one more confirmation for me. The following weekend, I attended my annual Holy Spirit women’s retreat where a woman prayed over me. She hesitated before sharing what she saw, thinking she’d lost her mind… “I see you on your belly doing an army crawl, arm over arm, under barbed wire. Does that mean anything?” I almost fell over. Yes! It meant everything! She saw me in the battle! I’m still processing what the Holy Spirit is doing not only in my clients but also in me. Watching the Divine Counselor at work is breathtaking. His love is fierce, intentional, and relentless. He is the ultimate and constant Battle Buddy. Y’all, we hit the Jesus jackpot. We are Jesus millionaires!
By Caroline Sholl January 24, 2026
How an honest view of ourselves makes more room for God
By Caroline Sholl August 29, 2025
Loved Much, Forgiven More: Finding Freedom in Christ’s Mercy
By Caroline Sholl August 29, 2025
Embracing Hardship as the Doorway to Resurrection Life
By Caroline Sholl August 15, 2025
What the Parable of the Prodigal Son Teaches Us About Self-Care
By Caroline Sholl July 29, 2025
My sweet big sister, Kitty Cleveland, invited me to be a guest on her "First Friday Friends" Morning Glory show to talk about God's lavish generosity and how he healed me of a lifelong "thorn in the flesh." Take a look!